![Best Shampoo For Golden Retriever [19 Options]](https://goldenretrieversinfo.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/07/Best-Shampoo-For-Golden-Retriever-19-Options-1024x451.jpg)
The long, smooth, and silky skin coat is of Golden Retriever enhances its beauty and draws the attention of everyone towards it. Thus, beautiful hair is undoubtedly one of the reasons for the immense popularity of this breed. But do you know that the owners must work very hard to maintain the beauty of this breed? Besides this, a Golden Retriever needs the best shampoo according to its hair type for a healthy skin coat.
The best shampoo for each Golden Retriever differs according to its skin coat type. But in general, the best shampoos with beneficial ingredients are
- Burt’s Bees Tearless Shampoo
- Rocco & Roxie Conditioning Shampoo
- Vet’s Best Allergy Itch Relief Shampoo
- Oatmeal And Aloe Earthbath All-Natural Pet Shampoo
- Furminator De-Shedding Oatmeal Shampoo
- Wahl Pet-Friendly Waterless No Rinse Shampoo
- PET CARE Sciences Oatmeal Dog Shampoo and Conditioner
- Veterinary Formula Solutions Triple Strength Dirty Dog Concentrated Shampoo
- Earth Bath All-Natural Coat Brightening Pet Shampoo
- Waterless Shampoo for Dogs
- TropiClean Luxury Shampoo & Conditioner
- Paws & Pals 5-In-1 Oatmeal Dog Shampoo
Moreover, I will be disclosing the pros, cons, and ingredients of all these shampoos further in this article. But before that, let us know a little about the things you must look at in the shampoo of your Golden Retriever to make it best.
What do you look for while buying shampoo for your pet?
How Often Should You Shampoo Your Golden Retriever?
A Golden Retriever has a double-layered, water-resistant, and dirt-repellent skin coat. Thus, it is less likely to get dirty.
Moreover, if you brush your pal daily, then there will be lesser chances of mating. So, these breeds can stay longer without bathing.
But despite the dirt-repellent coat of these dogs, you need to bathe your pal at least once a month regularly to maintain its hygiene. Besides this, as these dogs are mischievous and highly energetic, they might sometimes play in the mud, attach infectious substances to their fur, or start to smell bad. So, in these circumstances, you must bathe your pal beyond the bathing schedule.
Further, bathing removes the virus, bacteria, fungi, and dirt present in the dense fur of your Golden Retriever. Moreover, it also helps to distribute the essential natural oil throughout the skin coat of your pal. Thus, regular shampooing protects your pal and ensures the growth of a healthy hair coat.
However, you should buy the qualitative and best shampoo for the skin type of your Golden Retriever for an incredible bathing experience. So, do you know what should your pet’s shampoo include?
What Look For While Selecting Shampoo For Your Golden Retriever?
Apart from the friendly temperament and intelligence, the beautiful body structure and skin coat are few reasons for Golden Retriever’s outrageous popularity. Besides this, the skin coat plays a vital role in the healthier lifespan of your pal. So, it is essential to protect their fur and keep it clean.
To protect the natural charm and beauty of their skin coat, these dogs require qualitative products. However, the components you must look for in your pal’s shampoo vary according to its skin coat condition and health status.
But still, some of the things that your Golden Retriever’s shampoo must have are:
Hypoallergenic
To promote the appearance and effectiveness of the product, the producers often use some harmful chemicals that can trigger an allergic reaction. Thus, your pet’s shampoo needs to hypoallergenic with all-natural and organic ingredients.
Natural Ingredients
Although, shampoo with natural ingredients might not show faster benefit. But it helps promote the lustrous and natural appearance of your Golden Retriever’s skin coat in the long run.
Moreover, it is better to substitute harmful chemicals, artificial colors, and fragrances with natural ingredients to protect your pal’s skin coat.
Moisturizers
Environmental stress, humidity, and health issues can cause drying out of the skin in your Golden Retriever. Besides this, bathing might also make your pet’s coat dry and irritable. Thus, moisturizers are helpful to soothe and replenish the cracked skin areas of your pet.
However, using natural moisturizers like almond oil, oatmeal, and aloe vera is best for promoting the healthy skin coat of your pet.
pH Balance
Golden Retriever’s skin pH differs from humans. Thus, unlike humans, the skin pH of these breeds is around 6.5-7.5. So, you must select the shampoo according to the pH of your pet.
Usually, the shampoo with a pH higher than the pet’s skin might cause irritation and rashes in its skin. And similarly, the shampoo with pH below the dog’s pH results in cracking, drying out, and scales in the skin.
Deodorizers
Being a highly energetic dog breed, Golden Retrievers are more likely to get dirt and become smelly. So, your pet’s shampoo must have a natural deodorizer to mask the unpleasant smell.
Besides this, the soothing effect of deodorizers keeps the pet fresh and happy.
However, after you know what to look for in your pal’s shampoo, you might want to know the substance to avoid. Don’t you?
Are you aware of the substances that you must avoid in your pal’s shampoo?
What Should You Avoid In Your Golden Retriever’s Shampoo?
Despite the safety claims by the producers, shampoos still contain some ingredients that might be harmful to your pal in the long run. Therefore, you have to avoid such substances to ensure a healthier, active, and happier lifespan for your Golden Retriever.
Further, the harmful substances that you should avoid while choosing the best shampoo for your Golden Retriever are:
Cocamide DEA
Cocamide DEA is an emulsifying agent that is most common in cosmetic products. Moreover, the producers use this ingredient in the shampoo of humans and Golden Retriever to create enough foam for cleaning the hair.
But since cocamide DEA forms by mixing fatty acids of coconut with harsh unnatural chemicals, this ingredient is fatal for your pet. Furthermore, the International Agency on Cancer also states that this chemical increases the possibility of cancer in dogs. Therefore, try to use shampoo without this ingredient for your pet.
Alcohol
Alcohol absorbs the moisture from the skin coat of your pal. And thus, it leads to drying out of the skin. Besides this, ingestion of alcohol by your Golden Retriever results in toxicity and life-threatening consequences.
Furthermore, alcohol in your pet’s shampoo may cause skin irritation, rashes, and roughness of the skin coat. Thus, it is better to avoid it in your pet’s shampoo.
L-sulphates
Usually, this ingredient removes the unwanted dirt and grease from the skin coat of your Golden Retriever. Thus, it is a common component of your pal’s shampoo.
But since L-sulphates wash out the natural oils along with the unwanted grease substances from your dog’s skin coat. Thus, despite its usefulness, it is very harmful to your pet that damages its skin and hair.
Artificial Fragrances and Colors
Since Golden Retrievers are playful, they bring in the awful smell with them after playing. So, owners prefer shampoos with fragrances to mask the unpleasant smell coming from the skin coat of their dog.
However, even though these fragrances cover the smell for few hours, frequently using these harmful chemicals irritates and deteriorates the skin coat of your pal. Furthermore, the artificial colors that the producers use to enhance the appearance of their product stains the coat of your Golden Retriever. And thus, it might lead to fatal health issues like skin disorders, allergies, ear infections, eye diseases, cancer, etc.
Moreover, based on the ingredients and health status, there are different shampoos for Golden Retrievers. Do you know about them?
Best Shampoo For Golden Retriever
As the popularity of Golden Retriever is increasing immensely, there are many products available in the market for grooming and caring for this breed. Besides this, the skin coat of these dogs is vital for health and looks. So, you need to give special attention to the shampoo you use for these breeds.
Moreover, there are some of the shampoos with the best reviews:
Burt’s Bees Tearless Dog Shampoo
Burt’s Bees Tearless Dog Shampoo cleans, soothes, softens, and conditions the coat of your Golden Retriever. Usually, the ingredients like buttermilk and linseed oil present in this shampoo are beneficial. Thus, it soothes the skin and softens the fur of your pal.
Moreover, this is a mild shampoo with balanced pH that doesn’t interfere with the natural oils of your dog’s skin. Besides this, it is free from fragrances, sulfates, and harsh chemicals, and it is safe for your dog. Thus, the natural ingredients present in the shampoo make it safe for your pal.
In addition, Burt’s Bees Tearless shampoo is gentle and tear-free. So, it protects the sensitive eyes of your Golden Retriever.
Rocco & Roxie Conditioning Shampoo
Rocco & Roxie shampoo conditions and provides a natural glow to your Golden Retriever’s fur. Usually, the ingredients of this shampoo are argan oils, chamomile, and geranium that restores the natural luster of hair softens and soothes the skin, and strengthens the hair follicles of your pet. Besides this, other ingredients like peppermint oil complement the natural oils present in your dog’s skin, and Vitamin A contains antioxidants that promote a healthy skin coat.
Moreover, this shampoo gives a mild smell of honey to your pal’s fur after use. And thus, it helps to cover the unpleasant smell naturally.
Further, the shampoo is free from alcohol, parabens, sulfates, dyes, or colors. So, it is safe for your Golden Retriever. In addition, it alleviates ad soothes the skin coat of your pet by moisturizing it.
Moreover, the producers are confident about the usefulness of Rocco & Roxie shampoo. Hence, they give a 100% money-back guarantee. Thus, the product will for sure restore the natural charisma and beauty of your pal’s fur.
Vet’s Best Allergy Itch Relief Shampoo
Since Golden Retrievers love to play, they are more susceptible to suffer from allergies, skin disorders, parasitic infections, etc., while playing. Thus, Vet’s Best Allergy Itch Relief Shampoo is the perfect solution for you if your pal has such skin conditions. However, as the name suggests, this medicated shampoo needs the recommendation of the Vet.
Generally, the ingredients of this shampoo are oatmeal, tea tree oil, neem oil, aloe vera, and chamomile that acts against fleas, pollen, and other seasonal allergies and irritants affecting your pet’s fur. Moreover, this shampoo aims to alleviate the itchiness to soothe your pal’s skin so that your pal looks fresh and smells great.
Furthermore, when applied as per instruction, it is beneficial for managing dry spots and dermatitis flare-ups.
Furminator De-Shedding Oatmeal And Aloe
FURminator deShedding Ultra Premium Dog Shampoo contains omega fatty acids with Vitamin E for the smooth, silky, and lustrous skin coat of your Golden Retriever. Besides this, the natural flowers, aloe vera, and chamomile present in this shampoo acts miraculously in restoring the natural charm and beauty of your pal’s skin coat. Furthermore, other ingredients like cranberry and blueberry impart a natural and pleasant smell after use.
Moreover, as this shampoo is free of paraben and harsh chemicals, it is safe for your dog. Along with this, FURminator deShedding shampoo also controls the excess shedding of your pal’s hair. Thus, it enhances the dense and lustrous skin coat of your pet.
Earthbath All Natural Pet Shampoo
Earthbath All Natural Pet Shampoo moisturizes the dry, itchy, and flaky skin of Golden Retriever. Besides this, the colloidal oatmeal and organic aloe vera present in this shampoo help to soothe the irritating and re-moisturize the dry skin. Along with this, the natural components of this shampoo promote the healing of ruptured and cracked skin coats.
Moreover, this shampoo is dog-friendly and helps your pal get a shiny, long, and healthy hair coat. In addition, the natural component of this shampoo revives the original luster and charisma of your pal’s golden skin. Thus, your Golden Retriever will get soft, shiny, and healthy hair after using Earthbath all-natural shampoo.
Honest Paws 5-In-1 Oatmeal Dog Shampoo And Conditioner
Honest Paws 5-in-1 Oatmeal Dog Shampoo and Conditioner is a shampoo with a 5 in 1 benefit. Since this shampoo alone can do the five different works, you will save a lot of time and energy using it for bathing your pet. Moreover, according to the claim of Honest Paw Wellness, you can deodorize, clean, condition, moisturize and detangle the skin coat of your pal in a single wash.
Usually, the ingredients of Honest Paws 5-In-1 Oatmeal Dog Shampoo come from a natural source like coconut and palm. Thus, this shampoo is safe for your Golden Retriever. Besides this, the hydrating properties of soothing oats and aloe replenish the natural moisture of your pal’s skin and condition its fur to prevent matting.
In addition, the 5-in-1 oatmeal shampoo claims to be of the highest standard and safe for all dogs due to the absence of MEA, DEA, parabens, and sulfates.
Pet Care Sciences Dog Shampoo
PET CARE Sciences Oatmeal Dog Shampoo is a 5 in 1 shampoo that cleans, conditions, deodorizes, moisturizes, and detangles the skin coat of your pet. Further, it is the best shampoo for your Golden Retriever because it cleans thoroughly by penetrating the double skin coat. Besides this, the oatmeal and coconut oil give a beautiful appearance with a pleasant smell.
In addition, this shampoo is free from sulfates, cocamide DEA, phosphates, or parabens. Hence, it is safe for your dog.
The Best Brightening Shampoo For Golden Retrievers (Makondo Pet’s Dog Whitening Shampoo)
The lemon fruit, tea tree oil, carrot, peppermint, rosemary, and sage present in Makondo Pet’s Dog Whitening Shampoo whiten the skin coat of your pet. Further, these ingredients impart natural signs, glow, and pleasant smell in your pal’s fur.
In addition, this shampoo provides the best aromatherapy and relaxes your Golden Retriever. Along with this, the lemon and herbs present in the shampoo make your pal’s bathing experience incredible.
The Best Shampoo For Your Golden Retriever With Sensitive Skin (Pro Pet Works All Natural Oatmeal Dog Shampoo + Conditioner)
Since Golden Retriever has sensitive skin, it is more likely to suffer from allergies, rashes, and drying out of the skin. Therefore, Pro Pet Works All Natural Oatmeal Dog Shampoo is the best shampoo for your pal to moisturize the cracked areas and heal the damaged skin.
Furthermore, this shampoo contains vitamin A, D, E with oatmeal, aloe vera, almond oil, and natural fragrance. Thus, it makes your pal beautiful and improves the skin coat.
The Best Shampoo For Your Golden Retriever With Dandruff (Veterinary Formula Clinical Care Antiparasitic And Antiseborrheic Medicated Shampoo For Dogs)
Owners use this shampoo under the recommendation of the Vet to relieve inflamed scalp, greasy or waxy skin, red rashes, and flaky skin of your pet. Furthermore, Veterinary Formula Clinical Care Antiparasitic And Antiseborrheic Medicated Shampoo is a fast-acting shampoo to eliminate diseases like seborrhea, parasitic infection, and fungal infection in your pal.
Moreover, the ingredients of this shampoo are coat tar, salicylic acid, and micronized sulfur that treats the already affected skin. And thus, it will help to restore the natural beauty of your Golden Retriever. Besides this, the shampoo does not have harsh chemicals and dives a pH-balanced treatment for your dog.
The Best Moisturizing Shampoo For Your Golden Retriever With Dry Skin (Natural Oatmeal Dog-Shampoo And Conditioner)
Organic All Natural Oatmeal Dog-Shampoo is a plant-based moisturizing shampoo with high-quality natural ingredients like aloe vera, vitamins, coconut, vitamins, and fruit extracts beneficial for your pet. Furthermore, all these ingredients relieve itching in your pet’s skin. Besides this, they also give cooling effects and moisturize the inflamed skin areas of your pal.
Moreover, this shampoo is an excellent shampoo for allergic and sensitive skin coats and is free from a handful of chemicals. So, it is a great solution to improve the bathing experience of your pet.
The Best Heavy-Duty Shampoo For Your Golden Retriever (Veterinary Formula Solutions Triple Strength Dirty Dog Concentrated Shampoo)
As the name suggests, Veterinary Formula Solutions Triple Strength Dirty Dog Concentrated Shampoo has three times more active ingredients that promote the hair coat of your Golden Retriever. Usually, it is a dirt repellant formula with wheat protein, shea butter, aloe vera, and vitamin E that moisturizes and conditions your pet’s skin coat.
Furthermore, the apple and white tea fragrance of this shampoo have a long-lasting effect. So, your Golden Retriever will have a pleasant odor with a healthy skin coat after using this shampoo.
The Best Deorderizing Shampoo (Arm & Hammer Super Deodorizing Shampoo for Dogs)
Arm & Hammer Super Deodorizing Shampoo is the best shampoo to eliminate the odor in your Golden Retriever. Further, this shampoo has all-natural ingredients that are safe and effective for your pet.
Moreover, apply it regularly in the skin coat of your pal thoroughly and give special attention to the vulnerable areas like ears, tail, eyes, and paws for the best result. Along with this, the balanced pH of this shampoo makes it gentle to use for cleaning and freshening your pet.
2 In 1 Shampoo And Conditioner Formula
2 In 1 Shampoo And Conditioner Formula is the best shampoo to improve the sensitive, itchy, or allergy-prone skin coat of your pet. Moreover, it contains balanced pH with biodegradable and natural ingredients. Thus, this shampoo is gentle and safe for use.
Further, this formula relaxes the irritated skin areas and gives a pleasant look to your pal by promoting healthy and smooth hair growth. Besides this, the shampoo contains vitamins and antioxidants. Thus, it is beneficial for the sensitive skin of your pet.
Waterless Shampoo For Dogs
Waterless Shampoo For Dogs is a freshening shampoo foam that meets the requirement of every dog owner. Since this shampoo doesn’t need water, it is quick to use. Thus, it is best for old, injured, and ill dogs with difficulty in movement bathing.
Further, waterless shampoo is the best alternative for frequent bathing for your Golden Retriever. Moreover, this shampoo has a long-lasting fragrance that can eliminate the unpleasant smell of your pet. Along with this, this shampoo has a perfectly balanced pH and contains glycerin to moisture and soothe the delicate skin.
TropiClean Luxury Shampoo & Conditioner
TropiClean Luxury Shampoo is the best shampoo to clean and condition the skin coat of your Golden Retriever. Besides this, it detangles messy hair and matted fur for easy brushing. Thus, this shampoo promotes the healthy, smooth, shiny, and silky skin coat of your pet.
Furthermore, TropiClean shampoo contains papaya and coconut that give a sweet and natural scent after use. Moreover, this shampoo is the safest solution due to the absence of soap, paraben, alcohol, and dyes.
In addition, the ingredients present in this shampoo are from naturally occurring plants and minerals. Thus, this shampoo is qualitative and best for your Golden Retriever.
Paws & Pals 2-In-1 Oatmeal Dog Shampoo
Paws & Pals Natural Oatmeal Dog Shampoo is a shampoo that cleans and conditions the skin coat of your pet. Besides this, it also helps to mask the awful smell of your pet and detangles the matted hair. In addition, this shampoo is the best solution to moisturize and soothe the itchy skin coat of your Golden Retriever.
Further, the natural ingredients present in this shampoo helps to relieve the symptoms of allergies, dry skin, and hot spots in your pal’s coat. Moreover, the pro-vitamins of this shampoo have hydrating and healing properties. So, it enhances the quality and appearance of your pet’s fur.
Along with this, the tear-free formula of this shampoo helps to prevent eye disease, ear infections, and irritation while bathing your pet. Further, this shampoo is the perfect solution to balance the natural oils present in your pet’s skin for healthy hair growth.
Nature’s Miracle Supreme Odor Control Shampoo
Nature’s Miracle Supreme Odor Control Shampoo is free from harmful substances and safe for your Golden Retriever. Further, this shampoo is best for all dogs because of its natural and effective ingredients.
Usually, this shampoo controls excessive shedding. But along with this, it also restores the natural shine and luster of y our pal’s beautiful skin coat. Besides this, Nature’s miracle freshens your pal and masks the unpleasant order with a pink peony scent.
Wahl Dry Skin & Itch Relief Pet Shampoo for Dogs
Wahl Dry Skin & Itch Relief Pet Shampoo is an oatmeal formula pet shampoo that moisturizes the dry skin, cleans the dirty coats, and relief the itchiness of your pal. Moreover, the sodding agent of this shampoo contains a higher concentration of coconut that produces more lather for easy rinse-off.
Apart from this, Wahl dry shampoo is free from alcohol, paraben, PEG-80 and has a balanced pH to give your pet a soft and smooth coat. Besides this, the natural ingredients of this shampoo are safe, effective and impart an incredible smell and look to your pal.
Which shampoo might be best for your Golden Retriever?
What Are The Different Types Of Shampoos For Golden Retriever?
Like humans, each dog has a different preference and personality. Besides this, the requirement of your pal also differs according to its medical history, health condition, and age. So, based on their preference and need, there are different types of shampoos for a Golden Retriever.
And they are as follows:
- Puppy shampoo- for extra sensitive skin of puppies
- General-purpose shampoo – for regular use with hypoallergenic, all-natural, and moisturizing agents
- Flea and tick shampoo – aims to kill flea and tick. Further, this shampoo contains some chemicals. So, rinse it within ten minutes of application.
- Medicated shampoo- recommended by the Vet and contains antibacterial, antifungal, and antiseptic agents to eliminate the skin disorders of your pet.
- 2-in-1 shampoo- both cleans and conditions your pal’s skin coat at the same time.
- 5-in-1 shampoo- use to clean, condition, detangle, moisturize, and deodorize the skin coat of your pet. since a single shampoo has multiple purposes, it saves time and effort.
However, do you know how to bathe your pal using these products?
Some Bathing Tips For Your Golden Retriever
Since Golden Retrievers love water, bathing them isn’t difficult. But small puppies sometimes resent water and need some time to get familiar with water. In such cases, you must be extra careful and patient.
Besides this, here are some bathing tips for your Golden Retriever that might help you:
- Choose the best shampoo for your Golden Retriever.
- Brush the skin coat of your pal thoroughly.
- Soak your pet’s fur in lukewarm water.
- Gently apply the shampoo and massage your pet during application.
- Then, rinse off the shampoo from your dog. Always be careful and protect the ears and eyes of your pal.
- Apply the conditioner to the skin coat of your pal and rinse it.
- Further, use the mixture of vinegar and water for the complete elimination of infectious agents.
- Dry your pet’s skin coat completely using a dog-specific blow dryer.
- Don’t forget to brush your pal’s skin coat after drying.
Do you think shampooing is essential?
Since Golden Retriever has a lustrous skin coat naturally, you might think it might not need conditioner like you. Do you know what does conditioner does?
If you don’t, then read further to get your answer.
Does Your Golden Retriever Need A Conditioner?
Generally, most breeds of Golden Retrievers have long, straight, and dense hair. Thus, there are higher chances of matting and tangling in these breeds. Besides this, if allowed, these dogs play with the kids all day long and bring home different infection agents attached to their skin coats.
So, conditioner is essential to maintain the lustrous appearance of your pal’s skin coat and detangle the hair. And thus, your pet’s hair becomes soft, silky, smooth, and shiny. Along with this, the conditioner gives extra protection to the skin coat of your pet so that it cannot attach dirt, dust, and infectious agents.
However, sometimes the conditioner can induce skin irritation, attack dirt, and deteriorate the hair shafts for your pal. So, you must always ensure that the conditioner is safe for your pal before using it.
Do you use conditioner after shampooing your pal’s skin coat?
Why Shouldn’t You Use Human Shampoo And Conditioner?
Unlike humans, Golden Retrievers have a different body structure, metabolism, and functioning. Thus, the products beneficial for humans might not be effective for your pal.
Further, the skin and hair of this breed are more sensitive than humans. Hence, the harsh chemicals used to wash out oil and greasy from human skin can damage the skin coat of your pet.
Besides this, the pH level of Retrievers differs from humans. Therefore, human shampoos and conditioners can cause skin irritation, drying out, rashes, itching, and allergies in your pet. So, this shampoo might be harsh in your pal’s skin that leads to life-threatening consequences.
How To Reduce Odor In Golden Retriever?
Golden Retrievers are always playing outdoor. So, when they return home, there might be different germs, bacteria, viruses, and fungi attached to the dense skin coat. As a result, your pet becomes smelly.
Further, all these infectious agents can deteriorate the health condition and reduce the lifespan of your Golden Retriever. Hence, it is essential to remove the odor from your pal.
However, due to the dense coat of your pal, complete removal of the smell is quite impossible. But still, you can mask or reduce the odor by using the following ideas:
- Find out the root cause of the unpleasant smell in your pal. And then, you must eliminate the reason.
- Try using different shampoos that are safe and gives a natural and pleasant scent to your pet.
- Groom your Golden Retriever regularly.
- Don’t skip the scheduled bath of your pet.
- Brush your pet’s fur daily.
- Emphasize healthy meals with all the essential nutrients.
- Clean the teeth of your pet at least three a week.
- Wash the beddings of your pal once a week.
- Try and test different shampoos and conditioners until you find the best one.
- Avoid using unhealthy treats. Instead, use natural snacks for treats.
Summing up, Golden Retriever is a needy breed. So, you hold the responsibility of bathing, grooming, caring, and feeding your pal.
Besides this, your slight ignorance might be fatal for your pal. So, to keep your Golden Retriever happy, active and healthy, you need to think cautiously before deciding.
Further, I hope this article helped you in deciding the best shampoo for your Golden Retriever?
Which among the above is the best shampoo for your pal?
Was this article informative?
Do you have any suggestions?
Please write them in the comments.
